ADR-058: Pingora Integration — Embedded Connection Pool

• Status: 🔄 Superseded by ADR-073 (2026-10-25)
• Date: 2026-03-16
• Decision Makers: Christophe Aboulicam
• Related: ADR-024 (Gateway Modes), CAB-1847, CAB-1849

Context

Cloudflare's Pingora (Rust, Apache 2.0) replaced nginx and handles 1+ trillion requests/day. STOA Gateway is built on axum + reqwest + tokio. The question: how should STOA leverage Pingora?

Why Pingora

The Business Case (decisive factor)

Signal	axum-only	With Pingora
Enterprise pitch	"Custom Rust gateway"	"Built on Pingora — Cloudflare's proxy framework"
Competitive position	Same tier as custom proxies	Same tier as Cloudflare Workers, Fastly Compute
CISO checkbox	Unknown stack	Battle-tested at 1T+ req/day
OSS credibility	Generic framework	Infrastructure-grade pedigree
Market uniqueness	None	Only API gateway built on Pingora

No API gateway vendor — Kong, Gravitee, Envoy, agentgateway — uses Pingora. This is a first-mover advantage in positioning.

The Technical Case

Feature	reqwest (current)	Pingora Connector
Connection pool	Per-client instance	Shared across all workers (Cloudflare's key win)
H2 multiplexing	Per-connection	Global stream multiplexing
Pool reuse at scale	Degrades >10K RPS	Designed for 1T+ req/day
Zero-copy proxy	No (userspace copy)	Kernel splice/sendfile (future)

At under 1K RPS the difference is 0.5ms p95. At 50K+ RPS, shared pooling avoids connection exhaustion that per-client pools hit.

Options Evaluated

Option	Description	Effort	Verdict
A: Full migration	Replace axum with Pingora server	55+ pts	Rejected — rewrites 400+ routes
B: Sidecar	Pingora front-proxy → stoa-gateway	21 pts	Rejected — extra hop, thin value
C: Embedded	Pingora connector inside stoa-gateway	13 pts	Accepted
D: Patterns only	Copy Pingora patterns, don't use crate	0 pts	Superseded by C

Why Embedded (Option C) Won

• One binary — no sidecar, no extra hop, no deployment complexity
• Same marketing claim — "Built on Pingora" is equally true for embedded connector
• Genuine value — Pingora's shared pool is the actual Cloudflare advantage, not the server
• Feature-gated — --features pingora enables it; default build stays reqwest (no cmake dependency)
• Incremental — proxy path migrates to PingoraPool gradually; MCP/admin/auth stay on axum untouched

Decision

Embed pingora-core::connectors::http::Connector inside stoa-gateway behind a pingora feature flag.

Architecture

Client → stoa-gateway (:8080)
              │
              ├─ MCP / admin / auth / OAuth → axum handlers (unchanged)
              │
              └─ Proxy routes → PingoraPool.send_request()
                                    │
                                    └─ pingora-core shared connection pool
                                         → Backend (H1/H2, TLS, keepalive)

One binary. One port. One deployment. Pingora manages upstream connections; axum manages HTTP routing.

Implementation

PR	What
#1799	stoa-pingora/ standalone binary (sidecar POC — superseded)
#1801	PingoraPool embedded in stoa-gateway (production path)
#1803	CI/CD: FEATURES=kafka,pingora in Docker build

Phase Compatibility

Our ProxyPhase trait maps 1:1 to Pingora's ProxyHttp:

STOA ProxyPhase	Pingora ProxyHttp	Status
request_filter	request_filter	Match
upstream_select	upstream_peer	Match
upstream_request_filter	upstream_request_filter	Match
response_filter	upstream_response_filter	Match
logging	logging	Match
error_handler	error_while_proxy	Match

If a full Pingora migration is needed at v2.0, phase implementations port directly.

What STOA Has That Pingora Doesn't

Capability	STOA	Pingora
eBPF kernel-level HTTP parsing	XDP + TC programs	Not built-in
UAC policy enforcement at kernel level	BPF maps synced from gateway	Not built-in
WASM plugin runtime	wasmtime integration	Not built-in
MCP protocol (AI agent gateway)	Full SSE/WS/JSON-RPC	Not applicable
Multi-gateway federation	7 adapter types	Not applicable

STOA uses Pingora for what it does best (connection pooling) and adds layers Pingora doesn't offer.

Consequences

• Production image built with FEATURES=kafka,pingora (cmake required in Docker)
• PingoraPool available for proxy path; reqwest remains as fallback
• Default build (no features) still works without cmake dependency
• Marketing: "STOA Gateway — powered by Pingora's connection engine"
• NOTICE file includes Pingora Apache 2.0 attribution
• Re-evaluate full migration at v2.0 or 50K+ RPS